Steak Doneness Guide When You Can’t Decide

Written By Creative Eateries

From the deep red of rare to the rich brown crust of well-done, steak doneness is more than a preference it defines your entire meal. Order it too rare, and you might push the plate aside. Go too far, and you risk chewing through dry beef. Finding that sweet spot is the challenge every steak lover faces. 

This guide breaks down each level of doneness, what to expect on the plate, and how to choose with confidence. Whether you crave tenderness, juiciness, or full-on char, we’ll help you land on the steak that matches your taste.

Ultimate Guide on How to Decide Steak Doneness Without Regret

Choosing the perfect steak's doneness can feel like a high-stakes decision when dining out. It’s the final step in a long cooking process that determines whether you get a tender, juicy, and flavorful steak, or a dry, overcooked disappointment. Here's everything you need to know about ordering a steak at a restaurant, so you can confidently choose your degree of doneness and enjoy a perfect steak every time.

Understanding Steak Doneness Levels

The secret to ordering a steak you'll love is understanding the language of a great steakhouse. The doneness of your steak is measured by the meat’s internal temperature, which directly affects its texture and color. A chef ensures even cooking from the exterior to the centre. Here’s what to expect from rare to well-done.

  1. Blue/Very Rare: This steak is a step above raw meat. It has a warm exterior, but the meat remains cool and very soft inside, with a purplish-red color. It is cooked to an internal room temperature of 115-120°F (46-49°C).

  2. Rare: A rare steak has a warm, bright red centre and remains tender. It is cooked to an internal temperature of 130°F. This vibrant red color comes from myoglobin, a protein that carries oxygen throughout the meat.

  3. Medium Rare: This is the most popular choice for a reason. Cooked to 135°F, it is considered by many to be the ideal perfectly cooked steak. It has a warm, pink-to-red centre and a perfectly juicy texture. A good chef knows this is where the steak is done to perfection.

  4. Medium: A medium steak has a slight hint of pink in the centre and is noticeably firmer. It is cooked to 145-150°F (63-66°C).

  5. Medium Well: The medium-well steak has only a trace of pinkness and is much firmer. The brown color dominates the centre, as the cooking process has significantly changed the muscle fibers.

  6. Well-Done: Cooked to 165°F+ (74°C+), a well done steak has no pink at all. It is very firm and dry throughout.

Choosing Your Perfect Steak: A Diner's Guide

Your preferred degree of doneness is a personal choice, but the cut of meat and its thickness can guide your decision. Many chefs recommend certain levels to bring out the best in each cut, ensuring a juicy steak without a moment of regret.

How to Decide Based on the Cut

  1. A medium-rare steak is often considered the gold standard for premium cuts with rich marbling like a ribeye or filet mignon. This level provides the perfect balance of flavor and tenderness.

  2. For leaner cuts, a rare steak is a great choice to retain moisture.

  3. A medium steak is a popular compromise for those who want a bit more firmness but still want to avoid a dry steak.

  4. For thicker cuts, a professional chef can use different cooking methods, such as a low-temperature oven and then a quick sear on a grill or steak on a hot pan to ensure the meat is cooked throughout the meat without drying out.

What to Ask and Look For at the Restaurant

  1. When your steak arrives, you can get a sense of its firmness by how it responds to the gentle prod of a fork. This gives you a quick clue, but the real test is the first cut.

  2. Don't be afraid to politely ask your server to have your steak returned to the kitchen if it’s not to your liking. A great chef and restaurant team will want to ensure the doneness of your steak is just right.

What Are The Best Steak Restaurants In Singapore?

After mastering your steak doneness knowledge, the next step is finding the right place to put it to the test. Barossa Steak & Grill. A leading destination in Singapore for steak lovers, provides the ideal setting to experience a perfectly cooked steak. Known for its use of the Josper Grill, which locks in flavor and creates a superb crust, Barossa offers an extensive menu with a range of options for every preference.

Josper Grill: For Individuals

  1. For those dining alone, you can choose from premium options like the Australia Angus Grass-Fed Beef Striploin (220g) for $34, or the rich Australia Angus Grass-Fed Beef Ribeye (250g) at $38.

  2. If you're looking to try something different, the menu also features Tasmania Grass-Fed Lamb Rump Cap (200g) and a specialty Australia Pork Rack for $36.

  3. For a truly luxurious experience, you can select the highly-marbled Japan A5 Wagyu Striploin for $54 per 100g.

Josper Grill: For Group or Sharing

  1. If you're dining with a group, the sharing platters are a must-try. These larger cuts are designed to be enjoyed together.

  2. Choose from the Australia Black Angus Porterhouse (1kg) for $158, which serves 2-3 people, or the impressive Australia Black Angus Tomahawk (1.2kg) for $188, ideal for 3-4 people.

  3. For a taste of everything, the Trio Cuts Of Australia Grass-Fed Beef offers a combination of Ribeye, Striploin, and Tenderloin for $105, also serving 3-4 people.

Ultimately, finding the best steak restaurants in Singapore comes down to quality, technique, and variety. Barossa Steak & Grill stands out as a prime destination for a truly exceptional dining experience. With its expert use of the Josper Grill and a diverse menu that caters to every preference, it’s the perfect place to put your newfound knowledge to the test and enjoy a perfectly cooked steak.

Steak Doneness: Frequently Asked Questions for Diners

Q: Will the chef use a meat thermometer?

  1. Yes. A professional chef and kitchen staff will use a probe or a meat thermometer during the cooking process to ensure the steak is a perfectly cooked masterpiece. It’s part of their job to take out the guesswork.

Q: Why do steak restaurants suggest resting the steak?

  1. Resting the steak for a few minutes before slicing is crucial. The intense heat of the grill or sear pushes all the juice to the centre of the steak. By letting it rest, the juice has time to redistribute throughout the meat, ensuring your cooked steak remains juicy and tender.

Q: Is a medium-well steak okay for a good cut of meat?

  1. While a chef might recommend a lesser degree of doneness for premium cuts, it is all about your personal preference. A medium-well steak at 160°F will still be a great cut of meat and can be prepared in a way that minimizes the chance of being overcooked. A skilled chef can prepare your steak to this internal cooking temperature inside the meat with precision.

Final Thoughts on Choosing Your Steak, from Rare to Well Done

Deciding on steak doneness no longer has to be a source of anxiety. By understanding the different levels, you can confidently order a steak exactly to your liking, from rare to well done. While you won't need to worry about the specific minutes per side that the chef uses, knowing these simple rules ensures you'll get a perfect steak at any restaurant especially at a top-tier establishment like Barossa Steak & Grill without the regret.

Creative Eateries
Previous

How to Plan Baby First Birthday Singapore?
Next

Best Ala Carte Buffet Steak & Fries Singapore